Thursday, August 9, 2012

DeBoer v. Sr. Bridges of Sparks Fam. Hosp., 128 Nev. Adv. Op. 38 (Aug. 9, 2012)

Before Justices Cherry, Pickering, and Hardesty.  Opinion by Justice Cherry.
In this appeal, the court examined the duty of care owed by a medical facility when performing nonmedical functions. The Named Appellant, as guardian for a cognitively impaired adult, appealed the district court’s dismissal of a negligence action brought against a senior care facility in connection with the execution of a power of attorney that resulted in Appellant being injured by a third party. An employee of Respondent facilitated a power of attorney in favor of a third party, which was signed by Appellant. The third party financially exploited Appellant, and Appellant sued Respondent for breaching its duty of care by allowing Appellant to sign the power of attorney, when a reasonable investigation would have established that Appellant lacked the requisite mental competence to protect herself from exploitation. The district court dismissed the claim pursuant to a NRCP 12(b)(5) motion, finding that Respondent owed Appellant no duty beyond providing competent medical care. On appeal, the Supreme Court overturned the dismissal, establishing that because immunity from general liability cannot be enjoyed simply due to one’s legal status, medical facilities are required to conform to normal standards of reasonableness under general principles of tort law when performing nonmedical functions. Because potential factual issues existed as to whether Respondent acted negligently in carrying out nonmedical functions, the court reversed and remanded. (Mark Dunagan, Associate in the Reno office of McDonald Carano Wilson LLP).